TUB 121

Keys to inclusive cities: benchmarking integration policies at a European level | by Léa Champagne

Keys to inclusive cities: benchmarking immigrant integration policies at a European level

(full article in pdf) Trait d’Union Bruxelles 121 

by Léa Champagne, Project Officer INCLUCITIES and secretary of the Belgian delegation to the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe - BRULOCALIS.


Integration is one of the tools used to guarantee cohesion within society. In the spirit that it is presented by European institutions, integration appears to represent a process that is both dynamic and mutual. An interrelationship between the individual and society[3] and a political goal to be attained that ensures equal treatment and aims to offer third-country nationals rights and duties comparable to those of European Union citizens. When it comes to migration and borders, the image that comes to mind is that of crossing a line that separates two countries. However, in a migrant’s journey, the border represents more than that. Once they have arrived in the destination country, migrants have to deal with other types of ‘border’ or barrier, located within society itself, that proliferate as they acquire different ethnic, normative, cultural and socioeconomic connotations. These internal borders retain their function of exclusion and inclusion and act as identity markers. From this perspective, integration is the process of crossing these different barriers to acceptance within the community. Let us look at how these barriers can be crossed and the key factors and types of process that enable people to do so.

MigrationWork logo

MigrationWork’s experience of benchmarking integration

To provide a specific illustration of what is at stake, what is created and what happens in a benchmarking process, we interviewed Richard Stanton, the co-founder of Migration Work CIC.[4] Richard Stanton has managed many transnational learning projects for MigrationWork CIC, as the former president of the organisation he co-founded it in 2009. After working in international development and holding a position as an elected local councillor in a British town for 9 years, he worked on local community funding in UK and in other countries until he began to focus on issues of migrant reception and integration in cities in the 1990s. From 2000 onwards, he led the development of a policy on immigration and asylum issues for the Mayor of London in Europe’s most diverse city, before launching MigrationWork.[5]

What does ‘benchmark’ mean?[6]

“The term has existed for decades, although it is used in very different ways. It started off as a management tool in the private sector, which was then imported into government institutions in the 1980s and 1990s. Then, in the 2000, the EUROCITIES network of major European cities[7] began to adapt a version of the public sector’s toolkit for migrant integration policies.”

A far more active approach to integration was obviously necessary. That was when city leaders realised that they urgently needed to transform practices in their cities and to get the European institutions involved in settling and integrating refugees and other [categories of] migrants. Whilst other mayors’ initiatives also began tackling these issues, EUROCITIES took the initiative of coming up with benchmarks for different aspects of integration, and then – with the European Commission’s support – putting them into practice in cities, in a series of mutual learning projects from 2007 onwards.[8]             

These projects started off by using peer-reviewed benchmarks, but this method has since evolved towards approaches based on mentoring and a ‘community of practices’. At MigrationWork CIC, we started applying benchmarks in 2009 in our capacity as moderators in a peer-review project for DG Employment [at the European Commission], assessing the effectiveness with which resources from the European Social Fund were used to promote migrants’ access to the job market. Since then, we have worked directly with EUROCITIES on several benchmarking projects, culminating in INCLUCITIES with the CEMR (Council of European Municipalities and Regions).”[9]

Is benchmarking currently useful for the development of migration and integration policies at a European level? 

“To resolve a challenge as complex as the integration of migrants, a whole series of tools will need to be developed, rather than a single approach that is supposed to become a ‘panacea’. Experience has shown that benchmarking is a powerful tool to reinforce integration work in Europe. It enables us to achieve two things that are crucial to this work: firstly, it establishes norms or standards for best practices that also incorporate European values; secondly, it permits a mutual learning process between practitioners in different Member States.”

How can we create benchmarks that correspond as closely as possible to practical realities?

“In various iterations, our benchmarks have shared a similar basic concept. They all focus on a specific subject or area within integration, such as the governance of integration, jobs or civic participation for migrants, the fight against discrimination in the provision of services, the attitude of the public to immigration, etc. Within this area, experts use literature and discussions with practitioners to study European experiences of projects at a local level to determine what has worked best to promote good results and to achieve the European political objectives in this area. In other words, we are searching for the European standard for best practice in every area of integration.”

 How does this standard become a benchmark?

“First of all, we dissect this successful experience into a series of essential elements: the actions required to put this best practice into effect. In the benchmark, each of these elements is identified as a key factor.[10] When MigrationWork started working on benchmarks, however, it made a significant change. Several previously completed projects had identified benchmarks with a wide range of distinct indicators, many of which were quantitative. Today, they are designed on the basis of a small number of key and essentially qualitative factors that describe what people do to ensure the success of their integration work. In general, they contain between eight and twelve such factors. Each of these is introduced in a short paragraph, supported by a few extra lines of text explaining why this factor makes an essential difference and how this factor will interact with other factors. Thus, in simple, transparent terms that are familiar to practitioners and activists, the benchmark enables these users to begin the analysis of what makes a successful integration practice.”

The goal of benchmarking is to work for change in the real world, not in an utopia! None of this learning happens in isolation. When applying the benchmark to improve its practices, the city or regional authority needs to be capable of demonstrating the independent conditions of its intentions that affect its chances of success. Lastly, an explicit list of these contextual factors is added to each benchmark, along with an invitation to users to refer to them: from conditions in the labour market to national legislation and budgetary constraints.”

How can or should benchmarking processes use the experiences and practices of migrants and refugees, by considering them as stakeholders in integration, in the context of benchmarking?

“In all our benchmarks for integration work, no key factor recurs more often than the need to listen to the voices of migrants themselves to improve these projects. The same should apply to the task of benchmarking and transnational learning between cities. However, two reservations should be expressed. Migrant participation cannot be achieved overnight. The identification of migrants who are genuinely representative of local communities – in terms of their gender, age and other categories of representation – and who also have time to engage in these discussions can only be possible if there are existing links between the world of public authorities and that of the community (or volunteers): formal structures such as forums for migrants or informal links with women’s support groups or youth clubs, for example. Once the representatives have been found, they generally need an introduction to the concept of transnational learning.

Integration is a two-way process. More fundamentally, it is about ensuring that the entire city becomes a more egalitarian and friendly place. Consequently, we need to try to listen to non-migrant or ‘welcoming’ communities as well. Some parts of this ‘host’ population are already fully represented in local government, but others may be marginalised, with voices that are rarely heard. Giving them a place at the table in debates on integration practices can strengthen the learning process and can benefit all stakeholders."

What steps are needed to achieve this?

“The priority is to ensure that the transnational learning process can benefit from the expertise of refugees and migrants. In theory, this can be done by following the three steps. 

Preparation of the benchmark is the initial phase and involves researching what has worked best in projects at a European level. Clearly, we stand to gain a huge amount at this stage from comments by observers from migrant communities. Thus far, it has proved to be impossible to identify migrant participants in partner cities, to recruit them and to train them in time for this drafting work, when the project has just been launched. As next step, every mutual learning project needs people from a partner city or region to visit their counterpart’s location (physically or virtually) to explore the latter’s integration practice and to compare it with the benchmark. Migrants are included in these visiting teams as often as possible and are often among the most dedicated participants. This role, accompanied by preparatory training, gives them great scope to comment on the benchmark they have used and to suggest how it can be improved. In the third step we are brringing back information after ‘mutual learning’ visits. This final phase of the project involves an assessment of the benchmark. At this stage, given that the project activity and exchanges between the partner cities should have involved the participation of migrants and their associations in most of these places, we may hope to obtain feedback from some of them about the benchmark. In practice however, the feedback has been minimal, whether it comes from migrant communities or the authorities and partner NGOs, unless we organise a special workshop on ‘revising the benchmark’.

The long-term solution to this challenge seems fairly clear. In the context of a broader evolution towards more participative forms of local democracy for all residents, town councils and other service providers must start involving the representatives of communities of refugees and other migrants in regular, structured monitoring of the services and activities linked to their integration. This seems ambitious. The people recruited for the monitoring role will also need support, of course (including remuneration). However, by including this in local democratic practices, it should be possible to create a group of experts on migration who are better prepared to engage in transnational learning, specifically in terms of benchmarking.”

What are the two or three genuinely vital prerequisites to ensure a city’s successful benchmarking, whatever the area of integration work?

“In general, as I have said, benchmarks are intended for use in the context of collaborative enquiries by government bodies that are learning from each other. Most of the time, we and the other participants have found these exercises extremely rewarding. But there have also been disappointments.”

*Three important factors in ensuring that a benchmark works well in transnational learning projects:

  • A political direction: developing an integration practice involves a process of change over many years. If the mayor or local authorities do not believe in it, or if they are enthusiastic but are about to lose an election to politicians who oppose it, there may not be much point working to improve this practice. “All our experience in integration has confirmed that the specific change a city is trying to bring about through benchmarking will only happen if it is conducted consistently over time by politicians who have been elected to represent this city.”

  • Staff capacity: this seems obvious but it is crucial. The goal of benchmarking is to explore the practice in depth. Whatever the mutual learning model they adopt, the benchmark users will have to meet with many bodies and groups (and migrant communities in particular) to collect the information in the chosen city or region. They will need meeting rooms, digital connections, interpreters and maybe even accommodation. “A dedicated team in the ‘host’ city is a prerequisite to set all that up. You can’t leave one desperate staff member on their own to do the work of three people!”

  • Commitment to external stakeholders: the key factors in each benchmark include the municipality’s capacity to engage with a series of stakeholders from outside its own structure: migrant communities, local volunteer associations and social partners of all kinds, other public service providers in the city and probably agencies at other levels of government. “If its relations

---

*This is the second publication in a series of articles on integration of migrants and refugees in cities published in Trait d’Union  Bruxelles. Next article: Towards a local shift in the governance of the integration of migrants